Sunday, September 10, 2017

Where can we find a list of Breitbart advertisers?


This is an interesting question, because it takes us right to the heart of the matter.

The answer is: you can't.

And the reason for that is also the logic about all the work we do. In the kind of advertising that gives Breitbart, The Rebel, Geenstijl and Bvoltaire their ad dollars, or ad euros in the later two cases: these ads are not bought from Breitbart (& co), they are typically bought from Google or Facebook, and Google and Facebook will put them on any site they have a deal with until they've delivered the audience promised.

Two problems with this:

Firstly, many buyers don't understand what they're buying. Especially when it comes to the Facebook campaigns, many ad buyers think they're buying Facebook placements. In reality, they're buying Facebook + thousands of other sites, all around the world.

Secondly, Google and Facebook have been waaaay to tolerant about what sites they sign deals with. In essence, they have at least historically signed deals with everyone that has enough traffic. For example the four sites mentioned above.

In other words, there is no list of Breitbart advertisers, only a list, changing by the minute, of advertisers who forgot to block sites where they didn't want their ads. If some genius wrote a script to actually present that list, it would be obsolete an hour later.

This is also the explanation as to why, to get efficient results, there are only two ways:

Inform advertisers that they need to block hate sites if they don't want their ads (and their ad budgets) there;

Pressure especially Google and Facebook to clean up their act. It really is quite upsetting that decent advertisers are placed on sites like the ones mentioned above without their knowledge.

Sunday, September 3, 2017

The three levels of Youtube de-monetization

So, let's take a look on how Youtube ads are forcibly removed again. This is a subject where there's a lot of misunderstandings, and also (as we have noted before) an important subject, since Youtube ads are worth so much more than the website display ads that we usually deal with.

First level - category demonetization

The default on Youtube used to be that a campaign ran anywhere, unless you specifically asked that a video category or un uploader be removed (like the display network still operates). During the so-called adpocalypse in the spring of 2017, this was changed. This is what the default looks like now:




















For the cause at hand (making sure that advertisers don't fund extremism by mistake), this actually does take care of a tiny part of the problem. Since most advertisers don't change these defaults, ads don't turn up on "content not yet labeled", which essentially is videos from uploaders that aren't established enough to be labeled in the system. Meaning that when your average extremists start uploading from a new account, or from their personal accounts, there will be no ads until the system has determined what the videos are about, and hopefully has identified them for a second-level demonetization.

Btw "mature audiences", also excluded, is exactly what you think. Compared to Facebook and Instagram, Youtube is fairly tolerant when it comes to sex and nudity and will accept surprisingly much (but not porn), but it will put an 18-year-and-logged-in limit, and it will only put ads there from advertisers that have specifically said they're ok with it.

Second level - your video is not advertiser-friendly

This was what the adpocalypse of spring 2017 was about: Youtube suddenly came out very openly defining what was defined as not advertising friendly videos, and started de-monetizing millions of videos, making mistakes by the hundreds of thousands.

The list is fairly long (link here) and has all the usual suspects, such as violence, danger s acts, drug use, war, death and tragedies, terrorism etc. Please note that this also removes ads from some very serious news reporting. A graphic report about war atrocities in Syria will be demonetized even if it's a very important news story. Remember, this is not about what is good or bad content or important videos or videos we'd rather see not made; it's all about what kinds of videos constitute an environment where advertisers want to see their ads.

Anyone that has worked in live news reporting knows Youtube is right here, if you're live reporting from a disaster, advertisers don't want ad breaks even if the ratings are through the roof.

The most interesting for the Sleeping Giants purpose is this one:








Sounds good, right? But remember, this is only guidelines for advertising, not for what you can upload in general. However, this is definitely where we hit a piece of hypocrisy from Youtube's part.

Because this is what their Community Guidelines has to say when it comes to hate and bigotry:














And videos that break the community guidelines should be taken down. So why are we speaking about whether they can have ads or not, and it's even under the same headline?

This is the first point where the flagging comes in. If you see a video that you think is hateful in any of the ways listed above, please do flag it. (There's an instruction in this blog post.) Flagging does work ... in the long run. Your single flag on a single video might have no result at all, but channels or videos attracting a lot of flags eventually get attention.

Third level - limited state

These things are all connected. Channels that are linked to terrorism, extremism or hate, regularly and  also in the videos, may be put in the so-called limited state, meaning three things:

  • Completely de-monetized
  • No comments field
  • Will never be recommended by the platform

This is good. Not perfect, but much better than current see-nothing-hear-nothing-do-nothing method. This is where The Rebel Media, Lauren Southern, Breitbart and David Duke all belong.

This has not been fully implemented yet, but it's obvious how the candidates for it will be picked: from algorithms, from flags, and from second-level demonetization for hate speech.

Summing up

There really are things you can do. If you see something that you think is extremism, or promotes discrimination of or humiliates on the basis of ethnic origin, nationality, religion, disability, age, veteran status, sexual orientation, gender identity, FLAG IT. And specifically mention in the flag comment that you believe the video breaks community guidelines for hateful content.


Monday, August 14, 2017

How to exclude extremist videos from your YouTube campaign

This is how to make sure your ad video doesn't end up on a video from The Rebel Media, Lauren Southern or some other extremist YouTube channels that are indeed receiving ads, and if your ad is placed with them, 55% of what you have paid will go directly towards supporting extremism.

Getting safer - exclude specific extremists

Log in to your Adwords account.

Choose Placements in the left-hand column and then Exclusions in the header.

Choose Campaign and then select the campaign from which you want to exclude.

Select YouTube Channels and then Enter multiple placements.



Enter the complete URLs of the starting page of the YouTube channels you want to exclude. The ones you have excluded will show up in the box on the right.

You get the channel URL by clicking on the channel name of a video (under the title), which will take you to the channel's start page. From there, just copy the URL in the browser address field.

Getting really safe - buy defined packages

If you want to be really safe, buy your campaign not from Google but from a YouTube network (MCN). Typically, they will have rights to book ads towards their own network, and only their own network. This means that unless they have let neo-nazis into their network, and they haven't, you're completely safe.

If you're based in the Nordics, here are the main players that can sell a completely extremist-free campaign to you:

Splay (all Nordics)
United Screens (all Nordics)
Töttörö (Finland only)
Nordic Screens (Norway only)
Gonzo (Denmark only)

Sunday, August 6, 2017

Some comments on new Youtube standards on extremism


This is news on youtube policies: https://youtube.googleblog.com/2017/08/an-update-on-our-commitment-to-fight.html.

Especially, note this paragraph:

Tougher standards: We’ll soon be applying tougher treatment to videos that aren’t illegal but have been flagged by users as potential violations of our policies on hate speech and violent extremism. If we find that these videos don’t violate our policies but contain controversial religious or supremacist content, they will be placed in a limited state. The videos will remain on YouTube behind an interstitial, won’t be recommended, won’t be monetized, and won’t have key features including comments, suggested videos, and likes. We’ll begin to roll this new treatment out to videos on desktop versions of YouTube in the coming weeks, and will bring it to mobile experiences soon thereafter. These new approaches entail significant new internal tools and processes, and will take time to fully implement.

Now, my main concern is brand-safe advertising, and above all securing that no advertising money sponsors extremism by mistake.

With that angle to it, Youtube becomes extra important. Why? Because its ads are so much more valuable than the display ads delivered through Facebook Audience Network or Google's display network. Unless you click them, the display ads are worth very little, small fractions of cents, whereas a video ad on Youtube usually is worth a little more than a cent, and 55% of that ends up with the uploader.

From the looks of it, this is an excellent solution that Youtube has come up with. One of the first channels to enter this limited state seems to be David Duke's channel, which is an excellent place to start.

However, as usual with Youtube, they set up a system that can solve the problem, but then basically leave it to the Youtube users to knowingly or unknowingly fill the system with the incoming data it needs to work properly. In other words, people have to take the time to actually flag supremacist and hate videos, and when enough correct flags come in on a particular channel, that channel will be a candidate for entering the limited state.

In other words, please flag, and please flag correctly. Flag videos that really do promote supremacist views, hatred and violence. Do not flag videos because of your however well founded views on the uploader. If David Duke starts making cooking videos, they should not be flagged, no matter what you know about him.

Here's how to flag:

Go to the video in question. Click the three little dots labeled "More".









Choose "Report".













Then select "Hateful or abusive content", and from the drop-down "Promotes hatred or violence".













And add your comments, for example about towards what this video promotes hatred or violence. Done.



Saturday, June 3, 2017

How a sloppy ad buy finances hate

It's really very simple.

Let's say you own a popular e-commerce web site, and you've bought a $10,000 re-targeting campaign targeted towards people in the US who have previously visited your web site. You've used Google Adwords to buy.

You buy the ads in the auction at $0.14 per click. (There are different ways to buy, this is one.)

Your ads get placed on tens of thousands of web sites - all kinds, any sites that your previous customers visit and that are connected to the ad network you're buying from. And yes, since both Breitbart and The Rebel Media are fairly well visited sites, your ad gets placed there a lot.

The campaign will now go on until 71,429 clicks have been reached, which is the number that your $10,000 budget at least will get you. The money will now be divided according to where these clicks have been. Let's say 4,000 clicks come from Breitbart and 1,500 come from The Rebel Media.

When you get your $10,000 invoice from Google and pay it, Google will distribute the money as follows:

Google                   $3,200 (32%)
Breitbart                   $380 (68% * 4,000/71,429)
The Rebel                 $142 (68% * 1,500/71,429)
Other publishers    $6,278 (68%*65,929/71,429)

And that's how your ad money ends up in Steve Bannon's and Ezra Levant's pockets unless you blacklist Breitbart and The Rebel Media.

How the 👹 did my ad end up on Breitbart?




Almost always, the ad as been bought through Google Adwords or Facebook Audience Network. Essentially, they work very similarly, but let's use Google Adwords as an example.

If you own a web site, or for that matter a blog or a youtube channel, you can sign up for Google Adsense. When you have been accepted, you can easily define the spaces on your web site where Google may place ads.

All the marked ad spaces on all the web sites in the system - which in Google's case is over two million web sites - are controlled by the same ad servers and become one single ad inventory for customers to buy ad placements from.

Yes, Breitbart is one of the two million web sites. So are some other equally vicious web sites, such as therebel.media, geenstijl.nl and bvoltaire.fr.

Here's the key to how you ended up on Breitbart: Google (or Facebook, for that matter) is not a media company. It is not a publisher. They're tech platforms. They never said they publishers but everyone didn't really understand what that meant for you as an ad buyer: it means that they handed over almost all of the responsibility for ad placement to you, the ad buyer.

If you buy from a publisher, a media company, they'll take the responsibility not to place your ad in a brand-damaging context. If you buy from Google or Facebook, it's your problem.

Typically, the ad placements are then bought from the inventory using geographical, target group (age & sex) or re-targeting methods. Re-targeting is when you place the ads to people who have previously done something particular online, for example visited ebay.com.

The important thing here being that you're typically NOT buying where your ads will be placed, only towards what audience.

The "where" is a factor that you, as an ad buyer, need to force into the buy. If you don't, it will end up anywhere that matches your audience definition. Including Breitbart.

Friday, June 2, 2017

Translation of UNT article


(translation of this article: http://www.unt.se/nyheter/foretag-annonserar-ofrivilligt-pa-hatsajter-4664726.aspx)
Companies involuntarily advertising on hate sites
Companies using advertising networks for their Campaigns have to count on ending up on hate sites. The possibility for companies to have control over ad placements is minimal.

Breitbart News is a US web site and a platform for the so-called alt-right movement – an umbrella term for several right-wing extremist movements (anti-semitic, islamophobic, misogynic and openly rcsist).

This spring, several Swedish ads have been placed on the site. Among them, advertising from office-supplies company Office Depot, Zalando and Karolinska Institutet.

-  When we were notified of this, we had a discussion, and all in all it was an easy decision to remove the ad and make sure it doesn’t appear there again, says Camilla Magnusson, deputy Director of Communication at Karolinska institutet.

Twitter campaign

The notification about the ad being on Breitbart came from Sleeping Giants, an anonymous network created in the US with the purpose of making companies aware thet their ads are showing on hate sites, such as American Breitbart News, Canadian Rebel Media, French Boulevard Voltaire and Dutch Geenstijl.

”Racism, homophobia, misogyny and fake news are often financed by advertisers that haven't put the ads there on purpose. We make them aware.”, Sleeping Giants writes on its Swedish Twitter account.

- Our knowledge of this incident deepened our discussion about the fact that we don’t have control of our advertising material, Camilla Magnusson says.

Google and Facebook
Karolinska Institutet’s ad was a so-called remarketing campaign, where the ad follows the user over the internet. This is an example of how companies today can buy ad space without a target group, and this is often done in ad networks.

In this situation, the companies have only limited insight and seldom get to see the ad networks lists of where the ads may turn up.

- Platform owners such as Youtube, Google and Facebook don’t view themselves as publishers, so they hand over the responsibility to advertisers, says Tero Marjamäki, press secretary at the organization Swedish Advertisers.

The problem is wide-spread and getting more common, accordning to Marjamäki.

Creation of block lists
There is a method to stop ads from ending up on brand-damaging web sites. Advertisers themselves have the opportunity to introduce policies and block-list pages where they do not want to be present. But the platform owners can’t offer everyone the same service.

- It’s a problem that the level of transparency is depending on the size and resources of the advertiser, Marjamäki says.
- You should set up policies for the people handling your media buy, and demand complete lists to know what you have paid for, he adds.
But keeping yourself updated on all websites takes resources.
- It’s not possible to ho through the entire internet to decide what web sites you don’t want to be on, Camilla Magnusson says.

Annika Augustsson/TT 

Where can we find a list of Breitbart advertisers?

This is an interesting question, because it takes us right to the heart of the matter. The answer is: you can't. And the reason f...